Hiring Advice
The Perfect Candidate: Are We Making Recruitment Harder Than It Needs to Be?
By Poppy McNamara · 20 November 2026
When hiring for a specialist role, it's natural to have a clear picture of the ideal candidate. Specific technical skills, industry experience, qualifications and a certain number of years in the field can all seem essential.
But how often does that perfect candidate actually exist?
And more importantly, how many brilliant candidates are being overlooked because their CV doesn't match every requirement?
The Difference Between Essential and Desirable
There's nothing wrong with having high standards when recruiting. Some roles genuinely require particular technical expertise, qualifications or industry knowledge.
The challenge comes when everything on the job description starts to become a non-negotiable.
A candidate might have eight of the ten skills you're looking for, excellent relevant experience and a proven ability to learn. Yet they can be rejected because they haven't worked with one particular system or haven't spent their entire career in the same industry.
Sometimes, requirements that were originally considered desirable become increasingly important as the recruitment process progresses.
This isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hiring managers naturally develop a clearer understanding of what they need as they meet candidates and explore different backgrounds.
But when expectations change without revisiting the original requirements, it can make an already challenging search even harder.
The question worth asking is whether those missing skills are genuinely essential from day one, or whether they could be developed with the right support.
When the Perfect Candidate Becomes Hard to Find
Imagine a business looking to recruit an experienced technical professional.
The job description outlines a combination of specialist skills, industry knowledge, leadership experience and the ability to manage projects from start to finish.
Individually, none of these requirements seem particularly unusual.
The challenge comes when every single one becomes essential.
As the search progresses, several strong candidates emerge. Some have outstanding technical expertise but less experience in one specialist area. Others bring extensive project experience and broader commercial understanding but haven't worked with every tool or process listed.
Each candidate has something valuable to offer, but none matches the entire checklist.
Meanwhile, professionals who do possess every required skill are often operating at a more senior level, with salary expectations that reflect their experience.
Suddenly, the available talent pool becomes very small.
This is where a conversation about priorities can make a real difference.
Which skills are genuinely essential from day one? Which could be developed? And could someone who excels in the most important areas ultimately deliver more value than someone who simply meets every requirement on paper?
The answer isn't necessarily to lower expectations. It's to make sure those expectations reflect what the role actually needs.
Sometimes, finding the right candidate starts with deciding what really matters.
Experience Doesn't Always Equal Ability
Years of experience can be a useful indicator, but they don't always tell the full story.
Someone who's spent ten years doing the same thing isn't automatically a stronger candidate than someone who's spent five years adapting, solving new problems and taking on increasing responsibility.
This is particularly relevant in engineering and technology, where products, processes and tools are constantly evolving.
An ability to learn, solve problems and adapt can be just as valuable as experience with a particular technology.
Of course, some specialist positions require extensive hands-on experience that can't simply be replaced with enthusiasm or potential.
But there's a difference between lacking the foundations to perform a role and lacking experience with one specific tool or process.
Recognising that difference can open the door to candidates who might otherwise be overlooked.
What Doesn't Always Come Across on a CV
A CV is a summary of someone's career. It isn't a complete picture of what they're capable of.
It won't necessarily show how they approach an unfamiliar challenge, how quickly they pick up new skills or how they contribute to a team.
These qualities often become much clearer through a conversation.
That's one of the most valuable parts of recruitment. Getting beyond the keywords and understanding the person behind the experience.
A candidate whose background looks slightly different from the original requirements might bring fresh perspectives, transferable skills and valuable experience from another industry.
And sometimes, those differences are exactly what a team needs.
Are Your Expectations Reflecting the Market?
There's another important consideration when searching for the perfect candidate: what you're asking for needs to reflect what's realistically available.
The more specialist skills, industry experience and responsibilities a role requires, the smaller the pool of people who can genuinely meet those expectations.
And those who do often command higher salaries.
This doesn't mean businesses should automatically increase their budgets or compromise on essential requirements. Every organisation has its own priorities and constraints.
But it's worth considering whether the combination of skills, experience, salary and working arrangements is realistic.
When a vacancy has been open for months, the solution isn't always to keep searching for more candidates.
Sometimes, it's worth revisiting what the ideal candidate actually looks like.
Could a Little Flexibility Improve Your Hiring Process?
Before ruling someone out because they don't tick every box, consider a few questions:
- What's genuinely essential? Which skills would prevent someone from performing the role effectively if they didn't already have them?
- What could be learned? Are there systems, processes or technical skills that someone with the right foundations could pick up?
- Are transferable skills being recognised? Could experience from another industry bring value to the team?
- Does the salary reflect the expectations? Is the level of experience being requested realistic within the available budget?
- Have the requirements changed? Are the skills being prioritised during interviews still consistent with the original job description?
These conversations don't mean lowering standards.
They mean making informed decisions about where flexibility is possible and where it isn't.
Finding the Right Person, Not Just the Right Keywords
Ultimately, recruitment shouldn't be about finding the CV that most closely resembles a job description.
It should be about finding someone who can do the job, contribute to the team and continue developing as the business grows.
That might be the candidate who ticks every box. But it might also be someone whose potential isn't immediately obvious on paper.
At Humand Talent, we work with businesses recruiting for specialist roles across engineering and technology. We understand that some requirements simply can't be compromised, particularly when technical expertise is critical.
But we also know the value of having open conversations about hiring priorities, market availability and what makes someone genuinely suitable for a role.
Because sometimes, the most effective way to move a difficult search forward isn't to look harder for the perfect candidate.
It's to reconsider what perfect really means.
Struggling to find the right person for a specialist role?
At Humand Talent, we help businesses navigate challenging recruitment searches, understand the available talent market and identify candidates who can make a real difference.
Get in touch with our team to discuss your hiring needs.